How Does a Sailing Boat Actually Sail?
Lesson 7: The First Bit of Sailing Theory You Really Need
The surprising thing about sailing isn't that a boat can sail downwind. It's that it can sail towards the wind at all.
If you have never sailed before, the basic idea seems perfectly reasonable when the wind is behind the boat.
The wind blows.
It pushes the sail.
The boat goes forwards.
Excellent. Sailing explained.
Except that sailing boats can also travel across the wind and, rather remarkably, can make progress towards the direction the wind is coming from.
That seems much less obvious.
If the wind is coming from where you want to go, surely it should simply blow you backwards.
Yet watch a sailing dinghy travelling up a river or across a lake and you may see it zig-zagging steadily towards the wind.
How?
The answer lies in the interaction between two surprisingly simple things:
the sail above the water and the centreboard or keel below it.
Once you understand what those two are doing together, an enormous amount of sailing starts to make sense.
First: Which Way Is the Wind Actually Going?
Sailors describe the wind by where it is coming from, not where it is going.
So a northerly wind comes from the north and blows towards the south.
That sounds obvious when written down, but it is worth getting right because almost everything else we do in sailing depends upon knowing where the wind is coming from.
When I am introducing someone to sailing, one of the first questions I want them to keep asking is:
"Where is the wind?"
Not:
"Where am I going?"
Not:
"Which rope do I pull?"
But:
"Where is the wind coming from?"
Once you know that, you can begin making sensible decisions about everything else.
There are lots of ways of working it out.
Look at:
flags and burgees;
ripples on the water;
trees and reeds;
smoke;
other sailing boats;
telltales or ribbons on the rigging;
and, with experience, simply the feeling of the wind on your face.
A useful beginner's trick is to turn your head slowly until you can feel the wind equally on both cheeks.
You are now facing approximately into the wind.
That direction matters enormously.
A Sail Is Not Simply a Big Wind Catcher
When sailing downwind, the sail can behave rather like a large curved sheet being pushed by the wind.
But when we sail across the wind or towards it, something more interesting happens.
A properly trimmed sail develops a curved shape.
Air flows around that curved sail and the sail behaves, in a simplified sense, rather like an aircraft wing standing vertically.
The airflow around it produces an aerodynamic force.
There is plenty of sophisticated physics behind exactly how that force is generated, involving pressure differences, airflow and the deflection of air.
Fortunately, you do not need to solve the mathematics while sitting in a dinghy.
The important beginner's idea is this:
The wind flowing around the sail produces a force that is not simply pointing straight forwards.
Part of that force is trying to drive the boat forwards.
But another substantial part is trying to push the boat sideways.
And that creates our next problem.
Why Doesn't the Boat Simply Slide Sideways?
Imagine putting a sailing dinghy on an enormous sheet of ice.
Raise the sails and put the wind on the side.
What would happen?
Without anything providing sideways resistance, the boat could simply skid sideways.
Water gives us the opportunity to prevent that.
Underneath most sailing dinghies is a centreboard or daggerboard.
Larger sailing boats may have a fixed keel.
These underwater surfaces resist the boat's tendency to move sideways through the water.
The hull itself also contributes some resistance, but the centreboard is particularly important.
So we now have two systems working together:
Above the water: the sail interacts with the air.
Below the water: the centreboard interacts with the water.
The sail tries to push the boat partly forwards and partly sideways.
The centreboard strongly resists much of that sideways movement.
What remains is a useful forward component.
And now we have a sailing boat.
The Sail and Centreboard Are a Team
This is probably the most useful way for a beginner to think about it.
A sailing boat does not sail upwind because the sail somehow magically pulls it directly towards the wind.
It works because the forces created by the sail and underwater surfaces act together.
Think about squeezing a wet bar of soap between your fingers.
If you squeeze it from opposite sides, it can shoot forwards.
The analogy is far from perfect, but it gives us a useful mental picture.
The boat is effectively working between two moving fluids:
air above and water below.
The sail interacts with one.
The centreboard and rudder interact with the other.
The result can drive the boat forwards even when the wind is coming from somewhere ahead of the boat.
That is the clever part.
So Can We Sail Directly Into the Wind?
No.
And this is one of the most important things a new sailor needs to understand.
Point the bow directly towards the wind and the airflow over the sail can no longer maintain the useful aerodynamic force we need.
The sail begins to flap.
Sailors call this luffing.
If you remain pointing directly into the wind, the boat will slow down and may eventually stop.
You are now head to wind.
It is quite a useful position when you deliberately want to reduce the sail's driving force, but it is not a good way of travelling towards somewhere.
If you unintentionally stop there and cannot easily get moving again, sailors may say that the boat is in irons.
That expression sounds rather dramatic.
For a beginner it usually means:
"We've stopped, the sails are flapping and I need to work out which way to turn."
Welcome to the No-Go Zone
Imagine looking down from above at your boat.
Draw an arrow showing where the wind is coming from.
Immediately in front of the boat's possible sailing directions is an area into which the boat cannot sail effectively.
This is called the no-go zone.
Its exact size varies according to the boat, sails, conditions and sailing technique, but for beginner purposes imagine a wedge extending perhaps roughly 40 to 50 degrees either side of directly into the wind.
Point the boat inside that zone and the sails will begin losing their ability to drive the boat efficiently.
Point sufficiently far outside it and the sails can begin working again.
That gives us a wonderfully important fact:
We cannot sail directly towards the wind, but we can sail diagonally towards it.
How Do We Get Somewhere Directly Upwind?
We zig-zag.
More properly, we tack.
Suppose your destination is directly upwind.
You cannot point the bow straight at it.
Instead, you sail towards one side of the wind at the closest practical angle your boat will maintain.
After travelling some distance, you turn the bow through the wind and sail towards the other side.
Then you do it again.
Your actual route looks something like:
left — right — left — right.
But overall you are steadily making progress upwind.
This is known as beating to windward.
It may not be the shortest distance between two points, but it allows a sailing boat to reach a destination that would otherwise appear impossible.
Windward and Leeward
This brings us to two sailing words you will hear constantly.
Windward
Windward means the side towards the wind.
If the wind is coming across the boat from your right-hand side, the right-hand side is the windward side.
Leeward
Leeward is the side away from the wind.
In that same example, the left-hand side would be the leeward side.
You will hear these words used in all sorts of situations:
"Sit on the windward side."
"There's another boat to leeward."
"Move your weight to windward."
"The leeward mark is down there."
They can initially sound like unnecessary sailing jargon.
Very quickly, however, they become extremely useful because they describe positions relative to the wind, and the wind is what matters.
The Wind Changes the Whole Geometry of the Boat
One of the lovely things about learning to sail is discovering that the same boat behaves completely differently depending upon its angle to the wind.
Point directly into the wind:
The sails flap and you stop.
Turn slightly away:
The sails begin to fill and the boat moves.
Turn further away:
The sails need easing out.
Keep turning until the wind is behind you:
The sails may be well out from the boat and the whole feeling changes again.
The boat has not changed.
The wind has not necessarily changed.
What has changed is simply the angle between the boat and the wind.
That angle is at the heart of sailing.
Try This Without Even Leaving the Bank
You can begin understanding all of this before launching.
Stand beside a rigged dinghy on a reasonably breezy day.
First identify where the wind is coming from.
Now imagine the boat travelling directly towards it.
That is the head-to-wind direction.
Imagine the no-go zone spreading out on either side.
Now point towards a direction just outside that zone.
That could become an upwind sailing course.
Turn further round.
You are moving progressively towards sailing across the wind and eventually downwind.
You can even walk around the boat while imagining that the bow is pointing in different directions.
It sounds simple.
It is.
But this simple exercise begins creating something every sailor eventually develops:
a mental map of the wind.
Try It Again When You Are Afloat
Once safely afloat with an instructor or experienced sailor, watch what happens as the helm slowly turns the boat towards the wind.
Do not worry initially about steering.
Watch the sail.
As you turn closer towards the wind, eventually the front edge of the sail begins to flutter.
Turn closer still and more of the sail begins flapping.
Now turn away again.
At some point the sail fills.
The boat accelerates.
You have just crossed the boundary between an angle at which the sail cannot work effectively and one at which it can.
That experience teaches more than several pages of aerodynamics.
A Common Beginner Mistake: Pulling the Sail Tighter
There is an understandable instinct when a sail begins flapping.
Pull it in harder.
Sometimes that is exactly what is required.
But not always.
If you are pointing too close to the wind, pulling the sheet harder cannot change the laws of physics.
The boat may simply be inside the no-go zone.
The solution may instead be to turn the boat slightly away from the wind.
This is called bearing away.
As the boat comes out of the no-go zone, airflow can become properly established around the sail again and the boat begins moving.
Learning this distinction is important.
A flapping sail does not automatically mean:
"Pull the rope."
Sometimes it means:
"Change the direction of the boat."
The Centreboard Matters More Than Beginners Realise
The centreboard can easily look like one of the less exciting parts of a dinghy.
The sail is colourful.
The mast is obvious.
The rudder controls where we go.
The centreboard appears merely to stick down underneath the boat.
Yet remove its sideways resistance and the whole business of sailing efficiently across or towards the wind becomes much more difficult.
You can sometimes feel this very clearly when sailing.
The boat is not travelling precisely in the direction the bow is pointing.
There is usually some sideways movement as well.
This is known as leeway.
A good sailing boat minimises that unwanted sideways slipping while converting as much of the available aerodynamic force as possible into useful progress.
Again, the important beginner's message is wonderfully simple:
The sail needs the centreboard, and the centreboard needs the sail.
They work as a system.
Sailing Is About Balance, Not Brute Force
There is another lesson hidden inside all this.
Sailing is rarely about forcing the boat to do something.
You cannot make the boat sail directly into the wind simply by pulling the mainsheet harder.
You cannot demand that the wind arrives from somewhere more convenient.
Instead, you work with what is available.
You choose an angle the boat can sail.
You adjust the sail.
You balance the boat.
You observe what happens.
Then you make another adjustment.
That is one reason sailing becomes so satisfying.
You are constantly solving a moving puzzle involving the boat, wind and water.
And every few seconds the puzzle changes slightly.
Don't Worry About Understanding All the Physics Yet
If you start reading deeply into sailing aerodynamics you will soon encounter discussions about:
pressure;
circulation;
lift;
drag;
flow separation;
apparent wind;
angles of attack;
foil sections;
induced drag;
vortices.
All of these have their place.
But none of them needs to be mastered before your first sail.
For now, remember just five things.
Always know roughly where the wind is coming from.
The sail generates an aerodynamic force.
Some of that force tries to push the boat sideways.
The centreboard or keel resists much of that sideways movement.
The combination allows the boat to move forwards and even make progress towards the wind — but never directly into it.
Understand those five ideas and you already understand something fundamental about sailing.
Your Practical Challenge
Next time you are beside a sailing boat, do not immediately start worrying about ropes.
Stop for a moment.
Find the wind.
Then identify:
the windward side;
the leeward side;
the head-to-wind direction;
the approximate no-go zone;
two directions in which the boat could sail to make progress upwind.
If you are sailing with someone experienced, ask them to point the boat progressively closer to the wind while you watch the sails.
Notice the moment they begin to luff.
Then watch what happens when the helm bears away by just a few degrees.
The sails fill.
The boat begins accelerating.
You have just watched aerodynamic theory turn into sailing.
Suddenly the Boat Makes a Little More Sense
When you first stand beside a sailing dinghy, it can appear to be a rather complicated collection of sails, ropes, fittings and strangely named pieces of equipment.
But gradually the logic starts appearing.
The rudder helps determine where we point.
The sail interacts with the wind.
The centreboard resists sideways movement through the water.
And the sailor puts them all together.
Perhaps that is the extraordinary thing about sailing.
We cannot control the wind.
We cannot sail directly into it.
Yet by understanding it, we can use the wind to take us remarkably close to where it came from.
That is not just one of the most important ideas in learning to sail.
It is one of the reasons sailing remains so fascinating.
Next time you see a sailing boat apparently heading towards the wind, look carefully. It isn't defying physics at all. It is using physics beautifully.
My name is Philip. I started sailing when I was 65.
I joined a club and because my son had already been part of a club for many years - borrowing all types of boat. He knew what we needed and the type of boat I would require.
So we did by an RS Toura - a virtually unsinkable dinghy which has given me the confidence to experiment and learn and take my RYA exams and become a competent sailor and then to move up to the boat of my dreams - the A-Rater.
Coming up Next Lesson 8 Sailing feels mysterious until somebody gives you a clock face.
Wind from 12 o'clock.
Close hauled -> close reach -> beam reach -> broad reach -> run.
And one beautifully simple rule:
Towards the wind, sails in.
Away from the wind, sails out.
Once you understand the points of sail, the whole boat starts making sense.
Return to https://pmrsailing.uk/Lessons.html



