Starting a Race — Why Everyone Appears to Be Sailing the Wrong Way

Five minutes before a sailing race starts, nobody seems interested in sailing towards the first mark.

If you have never watched a sailing race start before, the whole thing can look slightly ridiculous.

The first mark may be clearly visible up the river, yet instead of sailing towards it, the competitors are sailing backwards and forwards near the starting line.

Some boats are reaching quickly across the river. Others are almost stationary.

One boat sails towards the line, turns away and comes back again. Another appears to be sailing in completely the wrong direction. Boats tack, gybe, slow down, accelerate and occasionally sail in circles.

Then a signal sounds.

Suddenly everything changes.

The apparently disorganised collection of boats converges on one invisible line and, ideally, crosses it at speed just as the race begins.

That is the art of the sailing start.

And once you understand what the boats are actually trying to achieve, those mysterious five minutes become one of the most fascinating parts of racing.

The Starting Line Changes Everything

Most beginners naturally think about a sailing race in the same way they might think about a running race.

There is a start.

There is a finish.

So when the race starts, everyone should simply head towards the destination.

But sailing has an important complication.

You cannot wait on the starting line.

Imagine ten runners being told:

"You may move around as much as you like before the starting gun, but you must not cross the line early. Ideally, you should arrive at the line already travelling at full speed at exactly the moment the gun sounds."

That would produce a very different-looking athletics start.

And that is essentially what sailors are doing.

The objective is not merely:

Cross the starting line after the start signal.

The real objective is closer to:

Cross the best part of the starting line, at full speed, travelling in the correct direction, at almost exactly the moment the race begins.

Those additional requirements explain much of the apparent chaos.

---

What Is the Five-Minute Sequence?

Club procedures vary, and the precise signals used depend on the sailing instructions and racing rules being used, so a sailor should always check the instructions for that particular event.

But a typical club start provides competitors with a countdown before the start.

For a beginner, it is useful to think of this as a sequence of changing jobs.

About five minutes to go: investigate

This is not the time to sit waiting.

I want to know:

• Where exactly is the starting line?

• Which end appears favoured?

• What is the wind doing?

• Is there significant current?

• Where are the other boats gathering?

• How long does it take my boat to travel certain distances?

• Can I cross the line comfortably on both tacks?

• Where do I want to be when the final minute begins?

You are gathering information.

Around four to three minutes: build a plan

Now I can start turning observations into a strategy.

Perhaps the left-hand end of the line appears slightly favoured.

Perhaps the right-hand side gives access to stronger wind.

Perhaps there is current pushing boats towards the line.

Perhaps one end is becoming extremely crowded.

The theoretically perfect starting position may therefore not be the best practical starting position.

That distinction becomes very important.

Two minutes: position the boat

Now things become more serious.

You want to manoeuvre into an area from which your intended start is actually possible.

Being in the perfect place with five minutes remaining means almost nothing.

Being in approximately the correct place with 30 seconds remaining means a great deal.

Final minute: time and distance

Now the questions become much more immediate.

How far am I from the line?

How quickly am I moving?

How quickly could I be moving?

Is there space below me?

Is another boat going to prevent me accelerating?

Am I early?

Am I late?

Do I need to slow down?

When should I sheet in and accelerate?

This is where a good start begins to feel less like waiting for a clock and more like solving a moving geometry problem.

---

Why Not Simply Wait Behind the Line?

You could.

And for somebody entering their first few races, starting conservatively is often perfectly sensible.

But there is a problem.

A sailing boat does not instantly accelerate to full speed.

Suppose two identical boats cross the starting line at exactly the same moment.

Boat A is already sailing at close to full speed.

Boat B has been almost stationary and has only just sheeted in.

Technically they have started together.

In practice, Boat A may establish a significant advantage within seconds.

This introduces one of the central ideas of starting:

Time on Distance

The skipper is constantly trying to answer a deceptively difficult question:

How long will it take me to reach the starting line from here?

That is time-on-distance judgement.

It sounds easy until you remember that the boat's speed is constantly changing.

Wind strength changes.

Gusts arrive.

Other boats interfere with your wind.

You may have to bear away.

You may need to tack.

Current may move you towards or away from the line.

And your boat may take several seconds to accelerate.

You are therefore not simply estimating distance.

You are estimating time required to cover a changing distance at a changing speed.

That is a skill which develops enormously with practice.

---

A Simple Time-on-Distance Exercise

There is an excellent exercise you can practise before racing.

Choose an imaginary line between two fixed objects.

Sail perhaps 30 seconds away from it.

Then try to return and cross the line exactly when your stopwatch reaches zero.

Do it again.

And again.

Try approaching at different speeds.

Try it in lighter wind.

Try approaching slowly and accelerating during the final ten seconds.

Very quickly you begin developing an intuitive relationship between distance, boat speed and time.

Eventually you stop thinking:

"That looks about 30 metres."

Instead you begin thinking:

"That feels like about 18 seconds."

That is much more useful to a racing sailor.

---

Why Do Boats Sail Away From the Line?

This is one of the strangest things for a spectator.

Thirty seconds before the start, a boat may deliberately turn away from the starting line.

Why?

Because it may be too early.

Imagine you are 20 seconds from the line but there are 35 seconds remaining.

Continuing directly towards the line would make you early.

You therefore need to lose approximately 15 seconds.

You might:

• ease the sails;

• luff slightly;

• bear away;

• sail parallel to the line;

• make a small turn;

• use a controlled manoeuvre to consume time.

You are not lost.

You are spending time.

That is an important way of thinking about starting manoeuvres.

---

Why Do Boats Circle Before the Start?

Sometimes boats appear to circle, loop or make repeated manoeuvres.

There can be several reasons.

They may simply be using manoeuvres to remain close to their intended starting area without crossing the line.

They may be trying to preserve freedom to manoeuvre.

They may be avoiding other boats.

They may be checking the line.

Or they may be trying to arrive at a particular position at a particular time.

A moving sailing boat is generally easier to control than one that has been allowed to stop completely.

The objective is therefore often to keep the boat alive while using up the remaining time.

That does not mean endlessly spinning around as fast as possible. Every unnecessary tack or gybe can cost speed and create additional risk.

Good starting manoeuvring should have a purpose.

---

The Invisible Line

Another difficulty for beginners is that there usually isn't a painted white line across the water.

The starting line exists between two defined points.

That means the sailor must mentally visualise a line across moving water.

This becomes particularly interesting on a river.

At Upper Thames, for example, we are not racing across an enormous open area of sea. Banks, trees, current, moored boats, other competitors and the available width of river can all influence the approach.

So you need to develop the ability to look sideways and judge:

Am I actually behind the line?

That is harder than it sounds.

---

What Is Line Bias?

Now we encounter one of the cleverer aspects of starting.

The two ends of the starting line are not necessarily equally good.

Suppose the first leg is approximately upwind.

If the starting line were perfectly square to the wind, neither end would have an inherent windward advantage.

But the wind rarely cooperates perfectly.

If the wind direction shifts, one end of the line may effectively become closer to the windward mark.

That is called the favoured end.

Sometimes the advantage is surprisingly large.

Imagine two boats starting simultaneously, one at each end of a long starting line.

Both may legally cross at exactly the same moment.

Yet one could effectively begin several boat lengths ahead because of the angle of the line to the wind.

That is why experienced sailors investigate the line before the start.

---

How Can You Test Which End Is Favoured?

There are several methods.

One simple approach is to sail along the starting line and compare its orientation with the wind.

Another is to position yourself near the middle and assess which end appears further upwind.

You can also observe boats sailing close-hauled from each end.

But there is an important warning here.

The favoured end of the line is not automatically the best place to start.

Suppose the committee-boat end gives a theoretical advantage of two metres.

Twenty boats have noticed.

They all want it.

Meanwhile, another part of the line has clean air and plenty of space.

For a developing racer, starting slightly away from the theoretically favoured end with clear air and room to accelerate may be vastly better than joining a compressed group of boats and emerging almost stationary.

The fastest theoretical start is useless if another boat prevents you executing it.

---

The Difference Between Position and Speed

Beginners often concentrate entirely on position.

They think:

"I need to be on the line when the race starts."

Experienced racers think about position plus speed.

Imagine two boats again.

With three seconds remaining:

Boat A is one metre behind the line but almost stationary.

Boat B is five metres behind but accelerating rapidly.

Which is better positioned?

Quite possibly Boat B.

The question is not simply where the boat is now.

It is:

Where will the boat be when the countdown reaches zero?

That is why sailing starts are dynamic.

---

Acceleration — The Part Beginners Often Miss

A boat needs time and space to accelerate.

If you are sitting with the sails flapping and five seconds remaining, simply pulling the sheets in may not produce instant speed.

You may need to bear away slightly.

The sails fill.

The boat begins moving.

Water starts flowing effectively over the centreboard and rudder.

The boat accelerates.

Then you can gradually head towards your intended close-hauled course.

This creates another important starting concept:

Protect your acceleration space.

A beautifully timed approach can be ruined if another boat occupies the water into which you intended to accelerate.

That is one reason boats interact so closely before a start.

Everyone is looking for space.

---

The Final Ten Seconds

This is where everything begins to come together.

Imagine I am approaching the line.

10 seconds: I am slightly behind where I need to be, but I have space.

Good.

I can accelerate.

8 seconds: Sheets coming in. Boat beginning to move.

6 seconds: Speed increasing. Check the line.

4 seconds: Perhaps slightly early. Can I feather up briefly without killing the boat?

3 seconds: Commit.

2 seconds: Keep speed.

1 second: Don't make an unnecessary steering movement now.

Start: Cross the line at speed.

And suddenly all those boats which appeared to be wandering aimlessly become a fleet heading towards the first mark.

---

What Happens If You Start Too Early?

Crossing the line before you are permitted to start can mean having to correct the error under the applicable rules and signals.

For somebody learning to race, that can be enormously disruptive.

You may have transformed a potentially excellent start into a recovery exercise.

This is why I would much rather see a new racer start a few seconds late with clear air than attempt a heroic front-row start and get it badly wrong.

Your first objective is not perfection.

It is control.

---

A Good Beginner's Starting Strategy

For your first races, I would keep the plan deliberately simple.

You do not need to win the start.

Try this instead:

1. Identify the starting line clearly.

2. Stay on the correct side of it.

3. Avoid the most congested part of the fleet.

4. Keep enough space to manoeuvre.

5. Try to have the boat moving before the start.

6. Cross the line shortly after the signal.

7. Sail into clear air if possible.

8. Concentrate on the first leg.

If you cross five seconds late but are moving quickly in clear air, you may have a much better race than somebody who crossed at exactly zero but immediately became trapped behind several other boats.

---

Starts Are Particularly Interesting on a River

River sailing adds another layer.

The wind may be disturbed by trees and buildings.

One side of the river may have noticeably more pressure than the other.

Current may affect your time-on-distance judgement.

The favoured end of the line may put you on the less attractive side of the river.

And there may simply be less room for everyone to manoeuvre.

This creates an interesting tactical compromise.

Suppose the left-hand end is slightly favoured by the wind direction, but you believe the right-hand side of the river will have substantially stronger wind after the start.

Where should you start?

There isn't necessarily a single correct answer.

And that is precisely what makes sailing interesting.

---

The Start Is Really a Prediction

The more I sail, the more I think of a race start as an exercise in prediction.

You are trying to predict:

• where your boat will be;

• how fast it will be travelling;

• what the wind will do;

• what the current will do;

• what the boats around you will do;

• and what tactical options you will have immediately afterwards.

You will sometimes get those predictions wrong.

Everyone does.

But every start gives you another opportunity to improve them.

That is why simply doing more starts is so valuable.

Even if you are not particularly interested in winning races, starting teaches boat handling extraordinarily quickly.

You practise acceleration.

You practise stopping.

You practise turning.

You practise judging speed.

You practise judging distance.

You practise looking outside the boat.

And you practise making decisions while other boats are changing the situation around you.

---

Try Watching a Start Differently

Next time you watch a sailing race, don't watch the first mark during the five minutes before the start.

Watch the starting area.

Choose one boat.

Ask yourself:

Why did they turn there?

Why did they slow down?

Why did they sail away from the line?

Why are they approaching from that angle?

Why did they choose that end?

Then watch what happens during the final 20 seconds.

Suddenly the apparent chaos begins to reveal its structure.

The boats aren't sailing randomly.

Each crew is trying to solve the same problem:

How do we arrive at exactly the right piece of water, travelling at exactly the right speed, at exactly the right moment?

And everyone is trying to solve it while everyone else is getting in the way.

That is why starting can become one of the most addictive parts of racing.

---

Your First Start Doesn't Need to Be Brilliant

If you are thinking about trying club racing for the first time, don't be intimidated by the experienced sailors manoeuvring close to the line.

You do not need to copy them immediately.

Give yourself some space.

Stay clear of the busiest area.

Keep the boat under control.

Start slightly late if necessary.

Then sail the course.

Afterwards, ask yourself one question:

Could I start two seconds better next time?

Then try again.

Because your first racing objective shouldn't be to execute a championship-level start.

It should be to cross the line under control, sail the race — and finish wanting another one.

And once you start trying to shave those few seconds from your starts, you may discover that the apparently chaotic five minutes before the gun are some of the most interesting five minutes in sailing.

Return to pmrsailing.uk https://pmrsailing.uk/sailing-lessons/How-to-sail-better.html

---

 

Your First Race — Forget Winning and Try These Five Things Instead

Your first racing objective shouldn't be to beat somebody. It should be to finish wanting another race.

For many people learning to sail, the word racing sounds rather more serious than it really needs to be.

You may imagine experienced sailors fighting for centimetres on the starting line, shouting rules at one another, executing perfect tacks and discussing tactics that seem to require a degree in applied mathematics.

Meanwhile, you are still thinking:

Which mark do I go around next?

That is perfectly all right.

In fact, one of the biggest mistakes we can make when introducing people to sailing is to present racing as something you do only after you have become a "good sailor".

I increasingly think the opposite is true.

Club racing can be one of the ways in which you become a better sailor.

You don't have to be particularly competitive. You certainly don't need to expect to win. Your first few races can simply give your sailing a purpose.

Instead of sailing around practising random tacks and gybes, suddenly there is a reason for everything:

• you have somewhere to start;

• somewhere to sail;

• marks to round;

• other boats to avoid;

• decisions to make;

• and a finish line to reach.

So if you are contemplating your first race, forget about winning.

Give yourself five much better objectives.

1. Start Cleanly

Notice that I haven't said:

Win the start.

For your first race, that really doesn't matter.

Your objective is simply to cross the starting line after the starting signal, sailing in approximately the right direction and without becoming involved in unnecessary trouble.

That is already an achievement.

A racing start can initially feel chaotic because several boats are trying to arrive at an imaginary line at almost exactly the same moment.

Experienced racers may be thinking about line bias, acceleration, positioning, clear air and which end of the line gives them the tactical advantage.

You don't need to think about all of that yet.

Instead, concentrate on three questions:

Where is the starting line?

Which side of it should I be before the start?

Which direction am I sailing afterwards?

If you cross the line five or ten seconds after some of the experienced boats, nothing terrible has happened.

You are racing.

Indeed, being slightly late but under control may be far better than arriving at exactly the right moment surrounded by boats and discovering that you don't know what to do next.

Give yourself some space

In your early races, space is enormously valuable.

Space gives you time to think.

It gives you room to tack.

It gives you room to accelerate.

And it reduces the likelihood of finding yourself in a situation where several racing rules suddenly become important at once.

There will be plenty of time later to learn the finer points of starting.

For race number one, a calm, controlled start is a very good start.

2. Keep Clear

This sounds almost ridiculously simple, but it may be the most important skill of your first few races.

Look around.

Know where the other boats are.

Try to anticipate where they are going.

And avoid putting yourself unnecessarily close to them.

Racing inevitably introduces situations where boats converge. As your experience develops, understanding right-of-way rules becomes an important part of racing.

But initially, you can make life considerably easier by developing good awareness.

Suppose you are sailing towards another boat and you are not entirely sure what is going to happen.

Don't wait until the boats are a metre apart before deciding.

Look early.

Think early.

Act early.

That is good seamanship as well as good racing.

Racing teaches you to look beyond your own boat

This is one of the reasons I think racing is so valuable for developing sailors.

When simply sailing backwards and forwards, it is very easy to become completely absorbed in your own boat.

Where is my tiller?

Where is my mainsheet?

Are my sails set correctly?

Am I pointing in the right direction?

Put ten boats on the same stretch of water and suddenly you have to broaden your attention.

You start looking at the whole sailing area.

Where are the other boats?

Where is the mark?

Where is the wind?

What is happening ahead?

That awareness is a major step in becoming a more capable sailor.

3. Sail the Correct Course

This may sound obvious.

It isn't always.

The first time somebody shows you a race course, it can look like a collection of letters, numbers, buoys and arrows apparently designed to test your memory rather than your sailing.

So simplify it.

Before the race, find out:

Where do I start?

What is my first mark?

Which way do I round it?

What comes next?

How many laps am I sailing?

Where is the finish?

If possible, look at the actual marks on the water rather than relying entirely on a diagram.

There is a considerable difference between understanding that you need to sail to "Mark 4" and actually knowing which physical object on the river is Mark 4.

Follow the course, not necessarily the boat ahead

Following another boat can be useful.

It can also be dangerous.

The boat ahead may be in a different class.

It may be sailing a different course.

It may be going to the bank for tactical reasons.

Or its helm may simply have made a mistake.

Use the other boats as useful information, but try to understand the course yourself.

Completing the correct course is a much more useful first-race achievement than worrying about your position.

4. Avoid Unnecessary Manoeuvres

When people begin racing, there can be a temptation to do too much.

Another boat tacks.

You tack.

Someone heads towards the opposite bank.

You follow them.

A boat changes direction.

You change direction.

Before long you have completed six tacks and travelled considerably farther than necessary.

Every manoeuvre has a cost.

During a tack, the boat turns through the wind and normally loses some speed. A poorly executed tack may lose considerably more.

A gybe can create similar disruption.

So ask yourself:

Do I actually need to manoeuvre?

If the answer is no, continuing to sail the boat well may be the better option.

Make the boat easy to sail

This is particularly important for beginners.

A first race is not the time to demonstrate every sailing technique you have ever learnt.

Concentrate on:

• keeping the boat moving;

• maintaining good balance;

• trimming the sails reasonably well;

• steering smoothly;

• looking ahead.

One good tack is better than three unnecessary ones.

And there is an interesting lesson hidden here.

As sailors become more experienced, they often discover that good racing is not necessarily about doing more.

It is frequently about making fewer unnecessary mistakes.

5. Finish

This is the big one.

Finish the race.

It doesn't matter if everybody else finished before you.

It doesn't matter if somebody sailed past you on every leg.

It doesn't matter if your start was late, one tack was dreadful and you went halfway towards the wrong mark before realising your mistake.

Cross the finishing line.

Because when you do, you have completed your first race.

And something rather important has happened.

The mysterious activity called "racing" is no longer mysterious.

You now know what it feels like.

You have experienced a start.

You have sailed a course.

You have rounded marks.

You have shared the water with other racing boats.

You have made decisions.

And you have finished.

Next time, you can improve one thing.

Your Second Race Can Have One Extra Objective

This is how I would encourage a new sailor to progress.

Don't try to fix everything simultaneously.

After your first race, think about one thing you could improve.

Perhaps:

"Next time I'll try to be a little closer to the line at the start."

Then perhaps:

"Next time I'll try to make my tacks smoother."

Later:

"I'll watch where the strongest wind is."

Then:

"I'll start thinking about which tack is actually taking me towards the mark."

And eventually you may find yourself thinking about shifts, headers, lifts, clear air, mark-rounding tactics and all the other subjects in this improving-your-sailing series.

But those things can come later.

What If You Finish Last?

Someone has to.

In every race.

And if this is your first race while somebody else has been racing for twenty years, comparing finishing positions doesn't tell you very much about how well you sailed.

Use a different measure.

Did you start more confidently?

Did you keep the boat moving?

Were your tacks better?

Did you recognise a wind shift?

Did you round the marks more cleanly?

Did you make fewer unnecessary manoeuvres?

Those are meaningful improvements.

The finishing order will look after itself later.

Racing Is Really a Collection of Sailing Lessons

This is perhaps the greatest reason for trying racing even if you don't consider yourself competitive.

A normal afternoon's sailing might give you a handful of manoeuvres.

A race gives you repeated practice.

You start.

You sail upwind.

You tack.

You judge other boats.

You round a mark.

You change sail trim.

You reach.

You gybe.

You round another mark.

You sail upwind again.

And throughout all of this, the other boats provide an immediate comparison.

If another boat suddenly sails away from you, you can start asking why.

Was it flatter?

Were its sails set differently?

Did it tack at a better moment?

Did it find stronger wind?

Was it simply being sailed better?

That makes racing an extraordinarily effective learning environment.

Five Objectives for Your First Race

So forget the results sheet for the moment.

Give yourself this much simpler scorecard:

1. Start cleanly.

Cross the line under control and without getting yourself into unnecessary difficulty.

2. Keep clear.

Look around, anticipate other boats and give yourself room.

3. Sail the correct course.

Know where you are going and which marks you need to round.

4. Avoid unnecessary manoeuvres.

Keep the boat moving and don't tack merely because somebody else has.

5. Finish.

Whatever happens along the way, complete the race.

Achieve those five things and I would call your first race a success.

Not because of where you finished.

Because you have established the foundations upon which everything else can be built.

The Most Important Question Comes Afterwards

When you cross the finishing line, don't immediately ask:

"Where did I come?"

Ask:

"Did I enjoy that?"

And perhaps:

"What could I do slightly better next time?"

If you are already looking across the water, watching the race officer preparing for another start and thinking:

"I'd quite like another go at that…"

then your first race has achieved exactly what it needed to achieve.

Because your first racing objective shouldn't be to beat somebody.

It should be to finish wanting another race.

---

A final thought from the river

On a narrow river, racing can initially seem particularly daunting. There may be trees affecting the wind, bends in the river, other boats nearby and rather less open water in which to sort everything out.

But those same challenges make river racing an excellent teacher.

You learn to look ahead.

You learn to anticipate.

You learn that every tack has a cost.

You learn to notice small changes in the wind.

And, perhaps most importantly, you learn that the sailors around you are not simply opponents. At a good sailing club, they are very often the people who will help you rig the boat, explain the course, answer a question about the rules and encourage you to come back for the next race.

So don't wait until you think you are "good enough" to race.

Enter a race to help yourself become good enough.

Start. Keep clear. Follow the course. Keep the boat moving. Finish.

Then come back and do it again.

Return to pmrsailing.uk https://pmrsailing.uk/sailing-lessons/How-to-sail-better.html

 

Do You Really Need to Race to Become a Better Sailor?

You don't have to care about winning for racing to make you a better sailor.

Mention yacht or dinghy racing to somebody who has recently learned to sail and you can sometimes see an immediate change in expression.

"I'm not interested in racing."

"I'm not competitive."

"I'm not good enough yet."

"I just want to enjoy sailing."

All of those are perfectly reasonable responses. Sailing does not have to involve racing. There is enormous pleasure in simply taking a boat out, exploring the river, enjoying the wind and water, and gradually becoming more confident.

But there is another way of looking at racing.

Instead of seeing a race as a competition that you have to win, think of it as a structured sailing exercise lasting perhaps an hour or two.

Suddenly racing becomes something rather different.

You get a start, several beats to windward, repeated tacks, reaches, runs, gybes, mark roundings, encounters with other boats, changing wind conditions and dozens of small decisions.

Then, at the end, you have something extremely useful:

comparison.

You can see what worked.

And, perhaps more importantly, what didn't.

Learning to Sail and Learning to Sail Well Are Different Things

When we first learn to sail, the objectives are understandably quite simple.

Can we rig the boat?

Can we leave the shore safely?

Can we sail towards a destination?

Can we tack?

Can we gybe?

Can we return safely?

Once those basic skills have been acquired, however, another stage begins.

The question changes from:

"Can I make the boat do this?"

to:

"Can I make the boat do this efficiently, consistently and almost automatically?"

That requires practice.

And racing provides an extraordinary amount of concentrated practice.

Consider Something as Simple as Tacking

Imagine going out for a pleasant afternoon sail.

You might tack perhaps ten times.

There is no particular urgency. If the tack is slightly untidy, it probably doesn't matter. The boat slows down, you sort everything out, and continue sailing.

Now imagine sailing a race on a narrow river.

You may tack repeatedly.

Each tack suddenly has consequences.

Did you lose too much speed?

Did you turn too far?

Did the sails come across smoothly?

Did the crew move at the right moment?

Did you emerge from the tack pointing in the right direction?

Did another boat gain two lengths while you were doing it?

Nothing terrible happens if the answer is yes.

But you have received immediate feedback.

That is why racing can accelerate learning.

Racing Makes You Repeat the Important Things

Many sports improve through repetition.

A tennis player serves repeatedly.

A golfer practises putting.

A musician plays scales.

Sailing is slightly different because simply "going sailing" does not necessarily guarantee that you repeatedly practise the skills you most need.

A race does.

During one relatively short race you may practise:

• starting;

• acceleration;

• close-hauled sailing;

• sail trim;

• boat balance;

• tacking;

• wind awareness;

• mark rounding;

• reaching;

• running;

• gybing;

• communication;

• positioning;

• rules and awareness of other boats;

• judging distance;

• tactical decision-making.

And then you do it all again on the next lap.

That is a remarkable amount of practice packed into one afternoon.

The Start Is an Extraordinary Sailing Lesson

Even if you completely ignore the competitive element, a race start is a fascinating sailing exercise.

You are trying to position the boat in a particular place at a particular time while maintaining control.

That requires several skills simultaneously.

You need to judge distance.

You need to judge speed.

You need to understand how quickly your boat accelerates.

You need to know how slowly it can sail while remaining manoeuvrable.

You need to understand the wind.

And you need to remain aware of the boats around you.

For a beginner, the first few starts can seem chaotic.

But gradually something interesting happens.

You begin to understand your boat much better.

You discover that slowing a sailing boat deliberately is a skill.

So is accelerating it.

So is holding position.

So is arriving somewhere at exactly the right moment.

Those skills remain useful even when there isn't a starting line anywhere in sight.

Racing Teaches You to Look Outside the Boat

One of the most important changes in a developing sailor is where they look.

Initially, almost everything happens inside the boat.

Where is the mainsheet?

Where do I put my feet?

What is the tiller doing?

Is the sail flapping?

Where is the centreboard control?

As those actions become more automatic, your attention begins to move outside the boat.

You start looking at the water.

You notice gusts approaching.

You notice quieter patches.

You see another boat suddenly heel.

You notice that boats on one side of the river appear to be moving faster.

You begin to recognise headers and lifts.

You start asking:

Why is that boat going faster than us?

That question is one of the great advantages of racing.

Other Boats Become Your Instruments

Without other boats nearby, judging your own performance can be surprisingly difficult.

You may feel fast.

You may be sailing beautifully.

The boat may feel balanced and comfortable.

But what does "fast" actually mean?

Put another similar boat beside you and suddenly you have a measuring instrument.

If the other boat is gradually moving ahead, something is different.

Perhaps they have better sail trim.

Perhaps they are sailing slightly freer.

Perhaps their boat is flatter.

Perhaps they found stronger wind.

Perhaps they sailed fewer metres.

Perhaps they simply made fewer mistakes.

The important thing is not necessarily beating them.

The important thing is asking:

"What are they doing differently?"

The Boat Ahead Can Become Your Teacher

This is particularly useful when sailing against experienced sailors.

Rather than becoming frustrated when somebody sails away from you, watch them.

Where are they sailing?

When do they tack?

How flat is their boat?

How are their sails trimmed?

Do they sail higher than you?

Or are they actually sailing slightly lower but much faster?

Where do they position themselves before a mark?

What happens when a gust arrives?

On a river such as the Thames, this becomes especially interesting because the fastest route may not always be obvious.

Trees, buildings, bends, current and disturbed airflow can make one part of the river very different from another.

The boat ahead may be telling you something about the wind.

Racing Forces Decisions

When simply cruising around, it is easy to postpone decisions.

"Perhaps we'll tack in a moment."

During a race, circumstances continually ask questions.

Do we tack now?

Do we continue towards the bank?

Is that dark patch of water a gust worth sailing towards?

Has the wind headed us?

Can we cross that boat?

Should we approach the mark from here?

Do we need to defend our position?

Not every decision will be correct.

That is exactly the point.

You make a decision.

Something happens.

You learn from the result.

Over time, those decisions become quicker and better.

Mark Roundings Are Brilliant Practice

Consider a simple windward mark.

You could approach it casually, tack several boat lengths away, sail around it and continue.

Nothing wrong with that.

But racing encourages precision.

How close can you approach safely?

When should you make your final tack?

Can you maintain speed?

Can the crew prepare the sheets before the turn?

Can you round the mark without swinging several metres wider than necessary?

Can you accelerate immediately afterwards?

A good mark rounding is really a sequence of small sailing skills performed smoothly.

The same is true of a gybe mark or leeward mark.

And because races contain several marks, you get repeated opportunities to improve.

Racing Exposes Small Mistakes

This can occasionally be uncomfortable, but it is extremely valuable.

When sailing alone, you can make a poor tack and hardly notice.

During a race, you may immediately see another boat gain.

That doesn't mean racing is cruel.

It means racing provides unusually clear feedback.

A slightly oversheeted sail.

Too much rudder movement.

A boat allowed to heel excessively.

A slow tack.

A badly timed gybe.

A wide mark rounding.

Individually, these may cost very little.

But over an entire race they accumulate.

That teaches one of the most important lessons in performance sailing:

Good sailing is often not about doing one spectacular thing. It is about avoiding dozens of small losses.

This Is Particularly Noticeable in a Fast Boat

Sailing an A-Rater such as Champagne makes this especially obvious.

A fast, responsive boat rewards good coordination, but it also makes mistakes very visible.

An unnecessary rudder movement creates drag.

A poorly timed manoeuvre costs momentum.

Incorrect crew positioning affects balance.

A delayed sail adjustment can leave power unused.

And because three people are working together, communication becomes part of boat speed.

The fascinating thing is that this doesn't necessarily make a performance boat a bad teacher.

Quite the opposite.

A responsive boat gives extremely clear feedback.

Do something well and you can often feel the boat accelerate.

Do something badly and the boat tells you immediately.

But What If You Aren't Competitive?

This is perhaps the most important point.

You don't have to be.

Your objective doesn't have to be:

"I must beat everyone."

It could simply be:

"Today I want to improve my starts."

Or:

"I want to make every tack smoother."

Or:

"I want to keep the boat flatter."

Or:

"I want to look at the water more."

Or:

"I want to understand why another boat is faster."

Your result on the sheet might say eighth.

But if your tacks were noticeably better than last week, you achieved something important.

You can race against your previous performance rather than against everybody else.

You Don't Even Have to Finish Every Race

For somebody new to racing, simply joining in can be enough.

Start at the back.

Give yourself space.

Sail the course.

Watch what everybody else does.

If necessary, retire and come back another day.

The objective of your first race does not have to be winning.

It might simply be:

Start, sail the correct course and finish.

That is already an achievement.

Next time, perhaps try to stay closer to another boat.

Then try to make better tacks.

Then concentrate on mark roundings.

Improvement can be gradual.

And No — Racing Is Not Compulsory

There are excellent sailors who rarely or never race.

Cruising develops different abilities.

Navigation.

Weather awareness.

Passage planning.

Anchoring.

Seamanship.

Boat maintenance.

Decision-making over longer periods.

Handling unfamiliar situations.

Sailing for pleasure without any competitive objective is completely valid.

Racing is simply another tool.

But it is a remarkably effective one.

Try Treating One Race as a Training Session

If you normally avoid racing because you don't consider yourself competitive, try an experiment.

Enter one club race.

Forget about the final position.

Choose one skill.

Perhaps:

"Today I am concentrating on smooth tacks."

Afterwards, ask yourself three questions:

What went well?

What repeatedly went wrong?

What will I try differently next time?

That turns racing into deliberate practice.

And suddenly the finishing position becomes only one small part of the afternoon.

The Real Race May Be Against Yourself

One of the pleasures of sailing is that improvement never really ends.

You can learn the basic controls relatively quickly.

But learning to read wind, balance a boat, anticipate gusts, trim sails accurately, manoeuvre efficiently and make good decisions can occupy a lifetime.

Racing compresses many of those learning opportunities into a short period.

It creates repetition.

It creates decisions.

It creates comparison.

And it creates immediate feedback.

So, do you really need to race to become a better sailor?

No.

But racing may be one of the fastest ways of discovering what you need to improve.

And perhaps that is the best reason to try it.

You don't have to care about winning for racing to make you a better sailor.

Sometimes the most useful boat to beat is simply the sailor you were last week.

Return to pmrsailing.uk https://pmrsailing.uk/sailing-lessons/How-to-sail-better.html

 

Why Fast Boats Punish Small Mistakes

The faster the boat, the less time it gives you to pretend you haven't made a mistake.

There is something wonderfully reassuring about a forgiving sailing boat.

Get the sail trim slightly wrong and it carries on. Make a rather untidy tack and it slows down, but soon gathers speed again. Steer a few degrees too much, sit in slightly the wrong place or react rather late to a gust, and the boat generally gives you enough time to sort things out.

Then you step into something faster.

Suddenly the rules seem to have changed.

A badly timed tack costs several boat lengths. A little too much rudder feels as though somebody has put the brakes on. A moment's hesitation in a gust can turn a beautifully balanced boat into something demanding immediate attention.

The rules haven't really changed.

The consequences have.

That is one reason I find faster boats so fascinating. They can be less forgiving, certainly, but that also makes them extraordinarily good teachers.

And sailing an A-Rater such as Champagne makes this particularly obvious.

Speed Changes the Timescale

Imagine two boats approaching a situation where the helm has three seconds to recognise what is happening and respond.

One is travelling at 3 knots.

The other is travelling at 9 knots.

During those three seconds, the faster boat travels three times as far.

That means the sailor has covered much more water before doing anything about the problem.

The relationship is wonderfully simple:

Distance = speed x time

The faster the boat travels, the more distance is consumed by hesitation.

That applies to almost everything:

• spotting a gust;

• deciding to tack;

• adjusting the sheets;

• changing crew position;

• approaching another boat;

• preparing for a mark rounding;

• reacting to a header;

• correcting an oversteer.

At low speed you often have time to think:

"Something isn't quite right here."

On a performance boat the conversation can become:

"Something isn't quite—oh."

Small Steering Errors Become Expensive

One of the easiest mistakes to make in any boat is excessive steering.

The rudder is wonderfully convenient. Move the tiller and the boat turns.

Unfortunately, the rudder isn't a free steering device.

Deflect it significantly and it creates drag.

A beginner will often steer almost continuously:

left...

right...

left again...

another correction...

The boat travels in a slightly wobbly line while the rudder repeatedly moves through relatively large angles.

On a slow training boat this may not feel particularly dramatic.

On a fast boat you can often feel the boat decelerate.

Good helming increasingly becomes about using tiny movements and, wherever possible, allowing the boat to steer itself through good balance, sail trim and crew position.

The aim isn't:

Steer the boat constantly.

It is:

Set the boat up so that very little steering is required.

That is a profound change in thinking.

The Rudder Is Often Correcting Another Mistake

This is where performance sailing becomes particularly interesting.

Suppose I find myself pulling hard on the tiller.

The immediate temptation is to think:

"I need more rudder."

But perhaps the real question should be:

"Why does the boat need so much rudder?"

Perhaps the boat is heeling excessively.

Perhaps the sails are oversheeted.

Perhaps the crew weight is badly positioned.

Perhaps the sail balance is wrong.

Perhaps we have reacted too slowly to a gust.

The rudder may simply be correcting something that went wrong several seconds earlier.

A fast boat exposes that chain of events remarkably clearly.

Poor Sail Trim Becomes Much More Obvious

A few centimetres of sheet movement can make surprisingly large differences.

On a slower boat, imperfect trim may produce a fairly modest reduction in speed.

On a performance boat, the boat may immediately tell you something is wrong.

Oversheet and it can feel strangled.

Ease too far and power disappears.

Allow too much heel and the rudder loads up.

Fail to adjust as the apparent wind changes and the sails that were correctly set moments ago may no longer be right.

This is particularly interesting because the faster the boat travels, the more important apparent wind becomes.

The sails respond not simply to the wind we feel standing on the bank, but to the combination of true wind and the wind created by the boat's own movement.

As the boat accelerates, that apparent wind changes.

So something rather wonderful happens.

Speed itself changes the wind experienced by the sails.

The boat accelerates.

The apparent wind changes.

The sails may need adjusting.

That adjustment can produce more speed.

Which changes the apparent wind again.

Fast sailing therefore becomes a continuous process rather than a sequence of fixed settings.

A Gust Is No Longer Something You Deal With Afterwards

On a gentle training sail, a gust arrives.

The boat heels.

The sailor notices.

Then something is done about it.

Perhaps the mainsheet is eased.

Perhaps the helm bears away slightly.

Perhaps somebody moves their weight.

That sequence might be adequate.

But performance sailing gradually teaches you something better:

Don't react to the gust when it hits you. React because you know it is coming.

Look upwind.

Watch the water.

Watch the boats ahead.

Look for darker patches.

Notice changes in the trees.

Watch other boats suddenly heel or accelerate.

Now the crew can prepare before the gust reaches the boat.

Weight moves.

Sheets are ready.

The helm anticipates the change.

Instead of:

gust → problem → reaction

you begin developing:

observation → preparation → gust → acceleration

That is a completely different way of sailing.

And it is much faster.

Fast Boats Punish Late Tacks

A tack is one of the clearest examples.

At beginner level, success means:

We changed from one tack to the other without capsizing.

Quite rightly.

Later, the standard changes.

Now we might ask:

How much speed did we lose?

How far did the boat turn?

Was the turn smooth?

Were the sails released at the right moment?

When was the jib brought across?

Did the crew movement help the turn?

Did the helm use too much rudder?

How quickly did the boat accelerate afterwards?

A poor tack can turn a fast boat temporarily into a slow boat.

And acceleration matters.

Suppose two identical boats are travelling at the same speed.

One performs a clean tack and quickly returns to full speed.

The other loses considerably more speed and takes several seconds longer to accelerate.

That difference doesn't disappear when both boats eventually reach the same speed again.

The first boat has already travelled farther.

The distance has gone.

That is why apparently small differences in manoeuvres can accumulate into enormous differences over a race.

One Bad Tack Doesn't Stay One Bad Tack

This becomes especially important on river sailing.

On open water there may be long periods between manoeuvres.

On a relatively narrow river such as the Thames, we can tack repeatedly.

Imagine one boat loses only one extra boat length on each tack compared with another.

That doesn't sound disastrous.

But make ten tacks and the accumulated loss is approximately ten boat lengths.

Twenty tacks?

Now the apparently insignificant error has become a substantial disadvantage.

This is one of the great lessons of racing:

You don't necessarily need one enormous mistake to lose a lot of distance. Lots of tiny mistakes will do it perfectly well.

Mark Roundings Magnify Everything

Marks provide another excellent demonstration.

Approaching a mark too quickly without preparation creates a cascade of problems.

The crew isn't ready.

The sheets aren't prepared.

The helm turns too late.

Too much rudder is used.

The sails are adjusted late.

Weight is in the wrong place.

The boat exits the mark slowly.

The mistake may have started ten or fifteen seconds before the actual rounding.

That is another characteristic of better sailing.

We stop asking:

"What went wrong at the mark?"

and start asking:

"When did the sequence that caused the bad rounding actually begin?"

Often the answer is surprisingly early.

Fast Boats Reward Planning

This is perhaps one of the biggest differences I have noticed.

In slower sailing, you can sometimes operate predominantly in the present.

In faster sailing, you increasingly have to operate in the future.

Where will we be in ten seconds?

What will the wind be doing there?

Which boat will we meet?

When do we need to tack?

Where does the crew need to be?

Which control needs adjusting?

What happens immediately after the mark?

Good crews therefore begin manoeuvres before they appear necessary.

That doesn't mean physically turning early.

It means preparing early.

The actual manoeuvre then looks remarkably simple.

Communication Becomes Part of Boat Speed

This becomes even more important in a multi-person boat.

On Champagne, three people aren't simply passengers sharing different jobs.

The crew needs to function as a system.

The forward crew may see something the helm hasn't seen.

The midhand may recognise a gust.

The helm may be concentrating on another boat.

Someone may need to change a control.

Someone may need to move.

Someone may need to prepare for the next manoeuvre.

Poor communication introduces delay.

And, as we established earlier:

Distance = speed x time

Every unnecessary second matters more when the boat is travelling quickly.

Good communication therefore doesn't have to mean constant conversation.

Often the opposite is true.

The best communication is short and unambiguous:

"Gust in five."

"Ready to tack."

"Boat to leeward."

"Ease."

"Ready."

Everybody understands what happens next.

Heel Is Another Form of Information

Fast boats are also remarkably good at telling you when their balance is wrong.

Excessive heel can change the underwater shape presented to the water and increase the amount of helm required.

Now the rudder angle increases.

Drag increases.

Speed falls.

Again, what initially appears to be a steering problem may actually be a balance problem.

Move the crew.

Flatten the boat.

Reduce the rudder load.

Suddenly everything becomes easier.

That is one reason instructors constantly talk about the Five Essentials.

They aren't five unrelated rules.

They interact.

Sail setting affects heel.

Heel affects helm.

Helm affects drag.

Course affects sail setting.

Boat balance affects almost everything.

A performance boat makes those relationships wonderfully visible.

The Boat Becomes a Measuring Instrument

This is one of my favourite things about sailing faster boats.

You begin to use the boat almost like a laboratory instrument.

Make a small change.

What happened?

Ease the sheet slightly.

Did the boat accelerate?

Move weight forward.

What changed?

Flatten the boat.

Did the helm become lighter?

Use less rudder through the tack.

Did we exit faster?

Change the jib trim.

What happened to pointing?

The boat provides immediate feedback.

Not always perfectly—wind and water are constantly changing—but sufficiently clearly that patterns emerge.

Performance sailing becomes an experiment repeated hundreds of times.

Change one thing. Observe the result. Learn. Repeat.

Champagne Is Particularly Interesting

Sailing Champagne, our A-Rater, makes all of this particularly noticeable.

An A-Rater is not a small modern skiff. It is a very different sort of performance boat: long, powerful, highly specialised and designed around the particular world of Thames sailing.

That makes the experience fascinating.

There is considerable sail area.

There are three people aboard.

There are multiple controls.

The river can be narrow.

The wind is frequently disturbed by trees, buildings, bends and the banks.

The next manoeuvre is often not very far away.

Everything is happening together.

And because the boat can move quickly, getting something wrong tends to become obvious remarkably rapidly.

That is challenging.

It is also enormously educational.

Why Beginners Shouldn't Be Frightened of Faster Boats

None of this means that beginners should immediately be put into the most demanding boat available.

A forgiving training boat exists for very good reasons.

It gives people time to understand:

• steering;

• points of sail;

• tacking;

• gybing;

• balance;

• sail setting;

• centreboard use;

• basic safety.

But once those foundations exist, sailing something more responsive can accelerate learning enormously.

A performance boat doesn't merely tell you that something is wrong.

It makes the consequence obvious.

That feedback is extremely valuable.

Slow Boats Can Hide Bad Habits

This may sound slightly unfair to slower boats, because they are superb teaching platforms.

But their forgiving nature can sometimes allow habits to survive.

Large rudder movements.

Late sail adjustments.

Poor anticipation.

Inconsistent balance.

Slow manoeuvre preparation.

The boat carries on.

A more responsive boat says:

"No. Try that again."

And it says it immediately.

That is why sailors sometimes improve dramatically after moving into faster equipment.

The boat has become their instructor.

The Goal Isn't Perfection

There is also an important psychological lesson here.

Nobody sails perfectly.

Certainly not me.

The objective isn't to eliminate every mistake.

It is to make mistakes:

smaller, earlier and easier to correct.

A good sailor may notice the boat beginning to heel and make a tiny adjustment.

A less experienced sailor notices once the boat is already heavily heeled and makes a large adjustment.

Both have corrected the same developing problem.

But one corrected it while it was still small.

That is one of the biggest differences experience brings.

Expert sailing often looks remarkably calm because the corrections are happening before the problems become obvious.

Fast Sailing Is Really About Anticipation

At first, sailing seems primarily physical.

Pull this rope.

Move the tiller.

Change sides.

Duck under the boom.

Later, it becomes increasingly observational.

Watch the water.

Feel the helm.

Listen to the sails.

Notice the heel.

Watch the boats ahead.

Feel acceleration.

Then it becomes anticipatory.

You aren't simply responding to what the boat is doing.

You are predicting what it will need next.

That is when sailing becomes extraordinarily satisfying.

The Faster Boat Is an Unforgiving—but Excellent—Teacher

Fast boats punish mistakes because speed compresses time.

Poor trim costs more.

Excessive steering creates obvious drag.

Late reactions consume more distance.

Bad manoeuvres throw away valuable momentum.

Poor communication introduces delays.

But there is another side to this.

Fast boats also reward good sailing immediately.

Get the balance right and the helm suddenly becomes lighter.

Trim correctly and the boat accelerates.

Execute a smooth tack and you feel the speed return.

See the gust early, prepare properly and instead of fighting the boat you accelerate with it.

That feedback can become addictive.

You begin chasing not simply speed, but that wonderful feeling when the boat, sails, crew, wind and water all seem to be working together.

And perhaps that is the real reason performance boats make such good teachers.

They don't allow us to hide our mistakes.

But they don't hide our improvements either.

The faster the boat, the less time it gives you to pretend you haven't made a mistake.

Fortunately, it also gives you a very good reason to learn not to make the same one twice.

Return to pmrsailing.uk https://pmrsailing.uk/sailing-lessons/How-to-sail-better.html