How to Protest Effectively After a Race
(Without falling out with your sailing friends)
Most of us would rather be ashore with a mug of tea than filling in a protest form.
But protests are part of racing – and when done properly, they protect fair sailing rather than ruin the atmosphere.
The key word here is properly.
1. Decide if it’s actually protest-worthy
Before adrenaline does the talking, ask yourself:
-
Was there a clear breach of the rules?
-
Did it affect the outcome of the race?
-
Could it be resolved by a quick word ashore instead?
On a river, things happen fast. Gusts, bends, moored boats, paddleboarders… not every incident needs a red flag moment.
💡 Rule of thumb: If you’re unsure which rule was broken, you’re probably not ready to protest yet.
2. Protest on the water – calmly and clearly
If you are going to protest, do it correctly:
-
Shout “Protest!” loudly and promptly
-
Identify the boat (sail number or name)
-
Display a red flag if required by your class rules
No commentary. No commentary with hand gestures. Just the facts.
This isn’t the time to argue the case – that comes later.
3. Make notes immediately after finishing
As soon as you’re ashore:
-
Sketch the incident
-
Note wind direction, stream, relative positions
-
Write down who was there (witnesses matter)
River racing protests are won and lost on position and timing, not volume.
4. Fill in the form properly
A protest form isn’t a rant – it’s a report.
Keep it:
-
Factual
-
Short
-
Focused on what happened, not what you felt happened
Avoid phrases like:
❌ “They were clearly in the wrong”
❌ “Everyone knows they always do this”
Stick to:
✅ “Boat A was on port tack. Boat B was on starboard tack. No avoiding action was taken.”
5. In the protest room: less drama, more diagrams
When you get to the hearing:
-
Let the diagram do the talking
-
Answer the questions you’re asked
-
Don’t interrupt (even when it’s painful)
Remember: the protest committee is there to establish facts, not crown a villain.
And yes – sometimes you will lose a protest even when you felt right. That’s racing.
6. Keep club spirit intact
The real test of good protesting happens after the decision:
-
Shake hands
-
Thank the committee
-
Go and make the tea
Good clubs survive because sailors can race hard and share a bar afterwards.
Final thought
Protests aren’t about winning arguments – they’re about learning, fairness, and safer racing.
Handled well, they make everyone better sailors… and keep river racing enjoyable for all.