Touch Up or Start Again? Planning Paint and Varnish Work
The Winter Boat Shed | Philip Russell, PMR Sailing
The painting may take an afternoon. Getting ready for it can take considerably longer.
The awkward bit of paintwork on our Thames A-Rater, Champagne, is exactly where people look to find out her name. The blue stern panel is damaged, it needs repainting, and we bought the boat second-hand. If somebody once had a tin marked “Champagne’s blue”, it hasn’t found its way to me.
Walk round the rest of the boat and it’s a different story. Most of the hull paint is sound. There are a few scrapes I’d like to touch up, but I can see little to gain from rubbing down an entire hull to deal with a handful of marks. The stern has given me an idea, though. What if we chose a second shade of blue and made a stripe across the back?
How far does a scratch really go?
I’d start with a wash, let the surface dry and look along the topsides in daylight. Light falling across a scratch shows up a raised edge that can disappear when you look straight at it. It’s worth taking a wider photograph as well as a close-up. On the screen at home, six inches of blue hull looks remarkably like every other six inches of blue hull.
For a shallow scrape with firmly attached paint all round it, I’d keep the repair small. Clean and degrease as the paint maker specifies, gently smooth the lip where the scratch meets sound paint, remove the dust and build the coating back up. If the scrape has exposed the surface beneath, that spot may need the system’s primer before it gets its blue topcoat. A scuff that washes off can come straight off the job list. International
The point at which I’d widen the repair is when I can no longer find a firm edge. If the paint keeps lifting as I prepare it, the damaged area is bigger than the original mark suggested. If several patches run into one another, preparing the panel to its nearest natural edge starts to make sense. And if an apparent scratch turns out to be a crack in the material underneath, I’d want to find out what caused it before choosing a tin of blue. International
Two ways to solve the blue problem
For the scattered scratches I want the closest match we can manage. I’d paint a couple of sample cards with the intended undercoat and finish, label the backs and let them dry. Then I can hold each one flat against a clean piece of hull, first in daylight and then in the shade of the lean-to. Tilting the cards will help me judge whether it’s the blue that differs or the shine. I’d make the final judgement from a few paces away. I can live with a touch-up I have to go looking for.
At the stern, even a small colour difference is likely to catch the eye beside the lettering. Here I’d choose a blue different enough to look deliberate. Before buying a tin, I can use a straight-on photograph of the stern to try two stripe widths. Does the narrow one cover the whole area that needs preparing? Does the wider one crowd the name? A second look from the aft quarter should tell us whether the ends sit well with the lines of the boat.
I’d also photograph the lettering square-on with a ruler alongside and record its position from the panel edges. If the repair reaches the name, that gives us a way to put it back in the right place. The stripe is still an idea. A few minutes spent moving its edges on a photograph is considerably cheaper than moving them on the boat.
What went into the original paint tin?
There are two things I’d like to learn from the previous owner. One is the colour code. The other is exactly what went into the original paint system. A photograph of a label or an old invoice could answer both.
That distinction matters. One-pack paint comes in a single component. A two-pack finish has a separate hardener, and some two-pack coatings can attack an older one-pack film and leave it wrinkled. For example, International’s guide for repainting fibreglass calls for stripping back to the underlying surface if the old coating is one-pack or unknown and you want to change to its two-pack system. That would turn our little touch-up into a rather different job. International
I’d ask the coating maker which system it supports over the finish we have, including any primer required on exposed patches. If it recommends a compatibility test, I’d follow its method on a concealed spot. The sample cards can settle the colour question. Testing on the boat tells us how the old finish behaves.
Why the varnish stops at the bow and one side
With the first coat on the bow, we can already follow the grain through the area where the pale water marks used to draw the eye. It’s tempting to follow that lovely finish all the way round Champagne. Then I remember the rear runner we’ve sent to Allspars for a quotation, and the ropes we’re sorting through for replacement.
So we’re concentrating this winter’s varnish work on the two areas where the finish was damaged, the bow and one side. On timber, I’d look closely at the edge of any milky or lifting varnish and check where water might have got underneath. Once exposed wood is dry, it needs the full build-up specified for the chosen varnish. Where the surrounding finish is sound, a joint or the end of a timber gives us a sensible place to finish a coat. Limiting the area means we can give those pieces the coats they need and keep money available for the rigging. epifanes.nl
Will Saturday’s coat be ready on Sunday?
That’s the question I’d ask before opening a tin in a British winter. The lean-to keeps the rain off Champagne, but the hull can still be cold from the previous night. I’d check the air temperature and humidity, measure the surface temperature and look at the overnight forecast. As the surface cools towards the dew point, moisture can settle on fresh work even under a roof. The conditions while the coat dries matter just as much as the conditions when the brush goes down. International
One example puts a weekend’s work in perspective. For Epifanes Clear Varnish, the maker gives about five hours to become dust-dry at 10°C and 40 hours before recoating. At 20°C, the indicative recoating time is 24 hours. Those figures assume 65% relative humidity and the specified film thickness. If I brushed on that particular varnish at noon on Saturday and conditions held at 10°C, the 40-hour point would be 4 am on Monday. There goes my plan for a second coat on Sunday afternoon. epifanes.nl
On a damp Saturday there’s still a worthwhile job. I can compare the dried blues, photograph the name and record the chosen product and colour code in the maintenance notebook. Whoever next has to touch up Champagne deserves a better starting point than “some sort of blue”.
What I’d like to see from the bank
When Champagne is back at Bourne End, I hope somebody standing on the bank can read her name, admire the timber at the bow and watch her go sailing. If they have to come closer to find the little hull touch-ups, the colour match will have done its job. And if they spot a different blue across the stern and ask, “Have you added a stripe?” — well, that might be the nicest thing anyone could say about the repair.






